Saturday, September 26 2015

Frequency really is freedom

Frequency really is freedom

One of the very constant and justified criticisms of the public transport in SEQ is the overall poor frequency, of both rail and bus, as you move out from the inner CBD core and surrounding suburbs, frequency drops off rapidly

Jarrett Walker coined the term " Frequency is freedom ". One of the most important determinants of patronage outcomes is that services must be frequent. Rail services at 30 minutes or hourly, or worse, connected to bus services at similar poor frequencies make it very difficult for people to use the system. It matters little if the buses are wrapped in pretty colours, there is free wifi on board trains and buses, and you can see your next train or bus connection is 50 minutes way with real time. What does drive patronage in the final analysis is how long do we have to wait?

The railway to Springfield Central has 30 minute off peak trains with very poor connecting and feeder bus arrangements. We do not know what the overall train or bus frequency will be for the Moreton Bay Rail Link, but past experiences in SEQ suggest we are unlikely to be surprised about service frequency, particularly off peak. Billions of dollars invested for very poor service arrangements.

There are constant claims by the authorities that there are not enough resources to increase frequency where it matters, out in the suburbs. Well maybe it is time for some new thinking.

Fifteen minute service is the without doubt the real aim. Perth WA, has generally 15 minute train frequency or better when it matters, supported by frequent feeder and connected bus services. Patronage on trains in Perth is 13 million more passengers annually than Brisbane, a city with a smaller population. It shows potentially what can be achieved in SEQ.

OK, how do we proceed from here? It might be time to think incrementally. It might be within resources sooner to aim for 20 minute train frequency as a transition to 15 minutes. On the outer Caboolture, Ipswich, Shorncliffe Cleveland lines, and Springfield Central and Kippa-Ring lines, a change from 30 minutes to 20 minutes frequency means effectively 3 trains per hour instead of 2. A significant improvement from the present situation. Twenty minute frequency on the Ipswich line will be still be manageable in terms of the freight train paths required.

Bus network reform for Brisbane will allow for increases in feeder and connecting buses in the suburbs to match the improved train frequency.

Fare reform alone will not drive patronage increases, there needs to be a significant boost in service frequency, particularly out in the suburbs.

Again I stress 15 minutes is the real aim, however if that is beyond the present resources, just maybe 20 minutes might be a good staging point. Other jurisdictions have done this with excellent results.

For example in Melbourne, both the Pakenham and Cranbourne lines run largely at 20 minute frequency off peak, they overlap at Dandenong, which means a 10 minute frequency between Dandenong and CBD!

Similar things can be achieved for SEQ.

New thinking required Queensland.

Thursday, June 12 2014

The fare fail - a blast from the past

I wrote the article below in January 2013. We are still waiting for a new fare structure (June 2014). Fare affordability has reached the lowest levels ever ( 31 May 2014: SEQ: Fare affordability crisis worsens ), patronage has stalled. The article below was submitted to the transport authorities  […]

Continue reading

Sunday, June 8 2014

The Seniors two go card trick

The go card for Seniors in SEQ has a two paid journey daily cap. What this means is that after a Senior has completed two paid journeys on a go card they can then travel free. This is a very inequitable fare structure for Seniors compared to simple flat fares that are commonplace elsewhere.  […]

Continue reading

Saturday, April 12 2014

See no evil, speak no evil, hear no evil - public transport data transparency in Queensland

Public transport data made available publicly in Queensland is very superficial and lacks currency and real detail. Why is this so? What should happen from here? Lets go back a little in time. TransLink used to publish the TransLink Tracker (  […]

Continue reading

Sunday, April 6 2014

The south-east Queensland fare fail ...

Fare data, feedback, community consensus has public transport fares in south-east Queensland as grossly unaffordable. How did this situation occur? What should happen from here? First - how did this occur? Following a fare freeze in 2009 (a state election year) a five year fare path was embarked on  […]

Continue reading

Friday, April 4 2014

Welcome to Bob's Blog!

Musings on public and active transport, and life! Welcome! I have been interested in railways and public transport for my entire life.  I am interested in getting the best results for our community in terms of transport mobility that is sustainable, is accessible and is affordable for all.  I am the  […]

Continue reading